On Thursday, Justice Minister Sean Fraser informed a committee of MPs that the Liberal government will not separate advance directives from its bill aimed at revising medically assisted dying legislation, allowing MPs to vote on the measure individually.
Fraser expressed, “I believe we have a chance to alleviate suffering, which is just as crucial, if not more so, than adhering to legislative deadlines.”
Conservative MPs on the justice committee challenged the minister, seeking clarity on why Bill C-41, the legislation he is proposing to update medical assistance in dying (MAID), is being fast-tracked through Parliament without the opportunity for MPs to vote separately on its two main amendments. This bill was presented in the House of Commons on October 27.
One of the amendments prohibits individuals from obtaining a medically assisted death solely based on a mental illness, while the other allows individuals with declining mental capacity to request MAID in advance.
“Why aren’t you dividing the bill? Why are you compelling parliamentarians to address what you acknowledge as a complex issue under a timeline that isn’t necessary for advance requests?” asked Conservative MP Andrew Lawton, directing his question at Fraser.
The government enacted MAID legislation in 2016. However, the Superior Court of Quebec invalidated the law in 2019 as it was restricted to those whose deaths were “reasonably foreseeable.”
Bill C-7, which passed through Parliament in March 2021, eliminated that stipulation, aligning with the court’s decision, while temporarily postponing the expansion of MAID to include cases solely involving mental illness until March 2023.
The provision regarding mental health was subsequently postponed to 2024 and again to March 2027, meaning that unless Bill C-41 is enacted or the government delays the date once more, MAID will automatically extend to cover mental illness in March of the upcoming year.
Fraser emphasizes the importance of preventing suffering
The amendment allowing individuals to provide advance consent when their illness will eventually impair their decision-making ability is not affected by legislative timelines.
“While there is a mandated timeline regarding the mental health aspect, I don’t want to imply that the advance request issue is not equally pressing,” Fraser noted, justifying his choice not to separate the bill.
The minister explained to MPs that the decision to maintain both amendments in the same bill was motivated not by medical recommendations but by his concern that further delaying advance requests could result in unnecessary suffering.
-
Ottawa to indefinitely extend MAID exclusion for people solely suffering from mental illness
-
Government to reveal next steps for medically assisted dying, justice minister says
Fraser expressed, “My drive to advance this issue promptly stems from discussions I’ve had with individuals who are in pain.”
“It is immensely difficult to sit down with someone who understands their life is nearing its end, compounded by the challenge of losing their ability to make choices for themselves.”
Ensuring proper safeguards
Fraser asserted that the matter has been thoroughly examined and that provided the appropriate safeguards are established to manage advance requests effectively, the legislation should move forward without delay.
He stated that Bill C-41 is secure, as a physician specializing in the relevant illness must approve the conditions under which MAID can be administered.
Fraser noted that two independent medical assessors must then evaluate whether the conditions validated by the expert doctor have been satisfied, confirming that the individual’s suffering is unbearable and the illness is terminal.
“Only then would the individual be deemed eligible for medical assistance in dying under the proposed framework,” he explained.
Fraser added that individuals who may no longer recognize themselves or others but appear content and engaged in life would not qualify, as they are not undergoing intolerable suffering.
Tag: rewrite-pending

